Labour Migrants During the Pandemic: A Comparative Perspective

  • PDF / 645,691 Bytes
  • 16 Pages / 439.37 x 666.142 pts Page_size
  • 111 Downloads / 230 Views

DOWNLOAD

REPORT


Labour Migrants During the Pandemic: A Comparative Perspective Arjan de Haan1 Accepted: 2 September 2020 © Indian Society of Labour Economics 2020

Abstract The COVID-19 pandemic and the accompanying policies of confinement or lockdown have been amply demonstrated and are possibly reinforcing economic, social and gender inequalities. Because of the nature of the measures that governments took in response to the health crisis, migrants—including the millions of labour migrants in Indian cities—have been placed in a particularly vulnerable situation. This essay provides a comparative and historical perspective of the conditions of migrant workers, arguing that the disadvantages migrants face are entrenched in economic and social structures, unearthed in this pandemic, and that alongside immediate social protection measures, policies need to address the deep-rooted barriers that keep migrants vulnerable. Keywords  Labour migrants · Circular migration · Inequalities · COVID-19 · Inclusive policies

1 Introduction The COVID-19 pandemic and the accompanying policies of confinement or lockdown have been amply demonstrated and are likely reinforcing inequalities. Economic inequalities are reinforced as the better-off are better able to protect themselves, either secure in their jobs, or by having the resources to support themselves during a downturn. Gender inequalities are reinforced as women tend to be in more vulnerable jobs and are exposed to health risks. Social and identity (race, caste, nationality) inequalities often intersect with socio-economic inequalities.

This is written in personal capacity and does not represent the view of IDRC nor its Board of Governors. * Arjan de Haan [email protected] 1



International Development Research Centre (IDRC), Ottawa, Canada

13

Vol.:(0123456789) ISLE



The Indian Journal of Labour Economics

Because of the nature of the measures governments around the world took in response to the health crisis, mobile populations have been placed in particularly vulnerable situations. Across the world, refugees are amongst the most vulnerable, their living conditions make containing the virus extra challenging, and stigmatisation likely increases. Labour migrants, similarly, often have poor living and working conditions, are exposed to health risks at work, have no social security or insurance to fall back on, and are often stigmatised. Labour migrants’ vulnerability manifested itself in extreme ways in India, when the government announced a lockdown, and big cities’ labour migrants found themselves in the void of having lost their job, sometimes their housing, and in large numbers of cases having lost their income, and therefore with no alternative but to return to their home villages. Their plight has been well described in the media, by civil society organizations filling the gaps government agencies should be playing, and the efforts of groups of researchers. This essay provides a comparative perspective of the conditions of migrant workers.1 I will summarise international experienc