Hegel and the Philosophy of Religion The Wofford Symposium
THE WOFFORD SYMPOSIUM: ITs PURPOSE, GENESIS, AND THEME The purpose of The Wofford Symposium was to stimulate original scholarship on the theme of the meeting, to provide a forum in philosophy of high quality in the area which Wofford College principally s
- PDF / 31,690,048 Bytes
- 314 Pages / 439.37 x 666.14 pts Page_size
- 76 Downloads / 234 Views
Hegel and the Philosophy of Religion The Wofford Symposium
Edited, and with Introduction by
DARREL E. CHRISTENSEN
In celebration of the Bi-centennial of the Birth of Hegel, 1970
MARTINUS NIJHOFF / THE HAGUE / 1970
© 1970 by Martinlls Nijhoff, The Hague, Netherlands
All rights reserved, including the right to translate or to reproduce this book or parts thereof in any form
ISBN 978-94-011-8439-7 ISBN 978-94-011-9152-4 (eBook) DOl 10.10071978-94-011-9152-4
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Preface Acknowledgements Abbreviations Introduction
VII
XIII
xv
SECTION I SOME HISTORICAL PRESUPPOSITIONS OF HEGEL'S SYSTEM, by Dieter Henrich (Heidelberg University) Comment by Charles E. Scott (Vanderbilt University) Comment by Eugene Thomas Long (Randolph-Macon College) Henrich: Reply to Commentators
25 45 50 55
SECTION II THE YOUNG HEGEL AND THE POSTULATES OF PRACTICAL REASON, by H. S. Harris (York University) Comment by W. E. Steinkraus (State University of N.Y., Oswego) Comment by Thomas N. Munson (DePaul University) Discussion
SECTION
61 79 85 89
III
HEGEL'S PHENOMENOLOGY OF MIND AS A DEVELOPMENT OF KANT'S BASIC ONTOLOGY, by W. H. Werkmeister (Florida State University) Comment by Murray Greene (New School of Social Research) Comment by George Schrader (Yale University) Werkmeister: Reply to Commentators
93 111 116 121
VI
Table of contents SECTION IV
HEGEL'S "UNHAPPY CONSCIOUSNESS" AND NIETZSCHE'S "SLAVE MoRALITY," by Murray Greene (New School of Social Research) Comment by Joseph C. Flay (Pennsylvania State University) Comment by Thomas J. J. Altizer (State University of N.Y., Stony Brook) Greene: Reply to Commentators
125 142 147 153
SECTION V HEGEL'S REINTERPRETATION OF THE DOCTRINE OF SPIRIT AND THE RELIGIOUS COMMUNITY, by John E. Smith (Yale University) Comment by P. Christopher Smith (Lowell State College) John E. Smith: Reply to P. Christopher Smith
157 178 184
SECTION VI HEGEL AND THE MARXIST-LENINIST CRITIQUE OF RELIGION, by George L. Kline (Bryn Mawr College) Comment by W. Winslow Shea (University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill) Comment by Ignas K. Skrupskelis (University of South Carolina) Kline: Reply to Commentators Discussion
187 203 208 212 216
SECTION VII "AUTHENTICITY" AND "WARRANTED BELIEF" IN HEGEL'S DIALECTIC OF RELIGION, by Darrel E. Christensen (Wofford College) Comment by J. N. Findlay (Yale University) Christensen: Reply to J. N. Findlay Discussion
217 249 255 258
SECTION VIII HEGEL ON THE IDENTITY OF CONTENT IN RELIGION AND PHILOSOPHY, by Quentin Lauer, S. J. (Fordham University) Comment by James Doull (Dalhousie University) Comment by Charles D. Darrett (Wofford College) Lauer: Reply to Commentators Discussion
261 279 284 289 292
Index
303
PREFACE
THE WOFFORD SYMPOSIUM:
ITs
PURPOSE, GENESIS, AND THEME
The purpose of The Wofford Symposium was to stimulate original scholarship on the theme of the meeting, to provide a forum in philosophy of high quality in the area which Wofford College principally serves, and to make available for publication this collection of papers, whic
